TY - JOUR
T1 - Comparison of GeneXpert MRSA/SA ETA assay with semi-quantitative and quantitative cultures and nuc gene-based qPCR for detection of Staphylococcus aureus in endotracheal aspirate samples
AU - Coppens, Jasmine
AU - Van Heirstraeten, Liesbet
AU - Ruzin, Alexey
AU - Yu, Li
AU - Timbermont, Leen
AU - Lammens, Christine
AU - Matheeussen, Veerle
AU - McCarthy, Michael
AU - Jorens, Philippe
AU - Leven, Margareta
AU - Kumar-Singh, Samir
AU - Goossens, Herman
AU - Malhotra-Kumar, Surbhi
N1 - FTX; DOAJ; (CC BY 4.0)
PY - 2019
Y1 - 2019
N2 - Introduction: Staphylococcus aureus (S. aureus) is a common cause of ventilator-associated pneumonia. Rapid and accurate detection of lower respiratory tract colonization and/or infection with S. aureus may inform targeted preventive and therapeutic strategies. To investigate this, we compared semi-quantitative (SQ)-culture results from 79 endotracheal aspirates (ETA) collected from mechanically-ventilated patients, to two culture and two non-culture-based methods for detection of S. aureus.Methods: ETA analyzed by routine SQ-culture on blood and colistin-nalidixic-acid agar was compared to: (i) quantitative (Q-) culture on chromogenic COLOREX™ Staph aureus; (ii) enrichment in brain-heart-infusion broth followed by plating on blood agar and COLOREX™; (iii) nuc-based TaqMan qPCR, and (iv) GeneXpert MRSA/SA ETA assay.Results: Of the 79 ETA samples analyzed by SQ-culture, 39 samples were positive, and 40 negative for S. aureus. Two samples negative for S. aureus by SQ-culture were, however, S. aureus-positive by the other four methods and were considered positive. Appending these two samples as positive in the SQ-culture results, sensitivities-specificities for Q-culture, enrichment-culture, TaqMan qPCR and GeneXpert were 100-95, 100-92, 100-53% and 100% - 100, respectively. The lower specificities of Q-culture, enrichment-culture, and TaqMan qPCR was because of their higher sensitivities, although TaqMan qPCR also detected S. aureus-specific extracellular DNA.Conclusion: This first evaluation of the GeneXpert MRSA/SA ETA assay with ETA samples found it to be highly sensitive, specific, user-friendly (hands-on time ~ 5 min.), and rapid (~ 66 min. assay time). Where this equipment is not available, we recommend implementing more sensitive culture-based methods for improved S. aureus detection in ETA samples.
AB - Introduction: Staphylococcus aureus (S. aureus) is a common cause of ventilator-associated pneumonia. Rapid and accurate detection of lower respiratory tract colonization and/or infection with S. aureus may inform targeted preventive and therapeutic strategies. To investigate this, we compared semi-quantitative (SQ)-culture results from 79 endotracheal aspirates (ETA) collected from mechanically-ventilated patients, to two culture and two non-culture-based methods for detection of S. aureus.Methods: ETA analyzed by routine SQ-culture on blood and colistin-nalidixic-acid agar was compared to: (i) quantitative (Q-) culture on chromogenic COLOREX™ Staph aureus; (ii) enrichment in brain-heart-infusion broth followed by plating on blood agar and COLOREX™; (iii) nuc-based TaqMan qPCR, and (iv) GeneXpert MRSA/SA ETA assay.Results: Of the 79 ETA samples analyzed by SQ-culture, 39 samples were positive, and 40 negative for S. aureus. Two samples negative for S. aureus by SQ-culture were, however, S. aureus-positive by the other four methods and were considered positive. Appending these two samples as positive in the SQ-culture results, sensitivities-specificities for Q-culture, enrichment-culture, TaqMan qPCR and GeneXpert were 100-95, 100-92, 100-53% and 100% - 100, respectively. The lower specificities of Q-culture, enrichment-culture, and TaqMan qPCR was because of their higher sensitivities, although TaqMan qPCR also detected S. aureus-specific extracellular DNA.Conclusion: This first evaluation of the GeneXpert MRSA/SA ETA assay with ETA samples found it to be highly sensitive, specific, user-friendly (hands-on time ~ 5 min.), and rapid (~ 66 min. assay time). Where this equipment is not available, we recommend implementing more sensitive culture-based methods for improved S. aureus detection in ETA samples.
KW - Bacterial Proteins/genetics
KW - Diagnostic Tests, Routine/methods
KW - Humans
KW - Methicillin-Resistant Staphylococcus aureus/classification
KW - Micrococcal Nuclease/genetics
KW - Pneumonia, Ventilator-Associated
KW - Real-Time Polymerase Chain Reaction
KW - Sensitivity and Specificity
KW - Staphylococcal Infections/diagnosis
KW - Staphylococcus aureus/classification
KW - Ventilators, Mechanical/microbiology
U2 - 10.1186/s13756-018-0460-8
DO - 10.1186/s13756-018-0460-8
M3 - A1: Web of Science-article
C2 - 30627428
SN - 2047-2994
VL - 8
JO - Antimicrobial Resistance and Infection Control
JF - Antimicrobial Resistance and Infection Control
M1 - 4
ER -